|Title||Referee's report by George Howard Darwin, on a paper 'The seismic effect of tidal stresses' by Richard Dixon Oldham|
|Date||7 May 1904|
|Description||Sectional Committee: Physics and chemistry|
If it had been titled "a statistical examination of earthquakes with respect to Solar time and seasons of the Year", it might with some modification have been accepted. As the work has been done he thinks it should be placed on record in some way. The method of studying these statistics is largely governed by theory, much of it faulty or inadequate, and it may be doubted whether the enormous labour has been well applied. He does not think they can accept the proof of tidal influence on earthquake frequency until all the series are examined for lunar periodicity, and are show to exhibit it in far more marked degree than solar periodicity. The author shows that there is apparently some tendency to solar periodicity, but he explains why he does not believe that the author has established the connection with tide-generating forces. Discusses the theoretical considerations which have governed the author's treatment of the statistics. He thinks it best to confine himself to pointing out how the investigation seems unsatisfactory. To indicate improvements to the method would make the report too long and might introduce 'controversial matter'.
In a letter dated 6 May 1904, addressed from Newham Grange, Cambridge, to the Chairman of the Physics Committee, he regrets having to make an unfavourable report and would have no objection in communicating with the author or Professor Judd. Notes this is a subject to which Dr [Charles] Chree has paid very particular attention and suggests his remarks are sent to Chree.
Endorsed on verso as received 9 May 1904.
|Physical description||Report on paper (type A) and letter on paper|
|Digital images||View item on Science in the Making|
|Related records in the catalogue||RR/16/220|
Fellows associated with this archive
|NA8198||Darwin; Sir; George Howard (1845 - 1912)||1845 - 1912|
|NA1706||Oldham; Richard Dixon (1858 - 1936)||1858 - 1936|
|NA1735||Chree; Charles (1860 - 1928)||1860 - 1928|