Referee's report by Arnold William Reinold, on a paper 'Electrification of air, of vapour of water, and of other gases' by William Thomson, Magnus Maclean and Alexander Galt Not recommended for publication in Philosophical Transactions. Only laboratory results are given in the paper and there is no discussion of them and no hypotheses linking the aspects of the paper together. It isn't an advance in current knowledge. Subject: Physics [Published in Philosophical Transactions A, 1898]. 12 July 1897