Referee's report by Arthur Farre, on a paper 'Note sur un organe, placé dans le cordon spermatique, et dont l'existence n'a pas été signalée par les anatomistes' by P Giraldes Not recommended for publication. Describes paper as 'very imperfect, especially as it pays claim to a degree of originality which it does not possess' Subject: Physiology [Published in Proceedings of the Royal Society, 1857]. 12 August 1858