Referee's report by William Fishburn Donkin, on a paper 'On the enumeration of x-edra having triedral summits, and an (x—1)-gonal base' by Thomas Penyngton Kirkman Unsure whether to recommend for publication in Philosophical Transactions. It 'treats a difficult problem with skill and success, the problem is only a very particular case of the general question suggested by it, and the method is practically inapplicable to the more extended cases'. Subject: Mathematics [Published in Philosophical Transactions, 1856]. 31 August 1855