Referee's report by Robert Stoneley, on a paper 'Tides in oceans bounded by meridians IV. Series solutions in terms of angular width of ocean: semidiurnal tides in narrow oceans V. Solutions by use of finite differences: semidiurnal tides' by Arthur Thomas Doodson Sectional Committee: Physics Recommended for publication in the 'Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society'. The two parts should be published together. Considers some of the tables unnecessary, but would like all the work to be available for future investigators. Suggests the tables be deposited in the Royal Society Library. Refers to Joseph Proudman. [Published in the Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society] Endorsed on verso as received 3 July 1939. [July 1939]