Referee's report by Neil Kensington Adam, on a paper 'Adsorption on evaporated tungsten films. I. Oxygen and carbon monoxide chemisorption and the determination of film surface areas' by Eric Keightley Rideal and B M W Trapnell Sectional committee: Chemistry Paper reference code: A101 Recommended for publication in Proceedings 'after re-writing.' Adam notes 'The paper seems to me hastily and clumsily written, and could probably be reduced in length with careful re-writing, by at least one-third'. Original manuscript report is accompanied by typed transcription. [Published in Proceedings A, 1951]. Date received not given. 18 June 1950