Referee's report by John Graham Kerr, on a paper 'A primitive dipnoan fish from the Lower Devonian of Germany' by W Lehmann and Thomas Stanley Westoll Sectional committee: Geology Paper reference code: B5 Recommended for publication in the Proceedings, with Thorpe's comments. Suggests if the paper is accepted the authors should restrict the paper to description and to [?] evolutionary interpretations. [Published in Proceedings B, 1952]. Date received not given. 17 February 1952