Referee's report [by Edward Armand Guggenheim], on a paper 'Thermodynamic aspects of the behaviour of sulphur in silicate and aluminate melts' by C J B Fincham and Frederick Denys Richardson Sectional committee: Chemistry Paper reference code: A159 States that the paper is of a high standard, but notes that because most of the work has been published already in more specialised journals 'it is therefore at least questionable whether the Proc. Roy. Soc. is the best place'. [Published in Proceedings A, 1953]. Received 18 August 1953 [August 1953]