Description | Containing referee's reports arranged alphabetically by the lead author of the paper submitted to the Royal Society for review in 1914.
Notable referees and authors include William Lawrence Balls, James Gray and Geoffrey Ingram Taylor.
When report is on a standard sheet (A), the questions are: 1. Whether the paper should or should not be published in the "Philosophical Transactions" 2. Whether, in the former case, it should be published in full or in part only, the part so to be published being indicated 3. Whether any modifications are necessary or desirable, and, if so, of what nature 4. Which illustrations (if any) accompanying the paper should be reproduced General remarks
When report is on a standard sheet (C), the questions are: 1. Should the paper be published in the "Proceedings"? 2. If published, should it be printed as it stands, or with modifications? 3. Should all the illustrations be published? 4. If not published, should it be read before the Society? General remarks
When report is on a standardised form (D), the questions are: 1. Whether or not the paper should be read before the Society 2. Whether the paper should or should not be published by the Society 3. Whether, in the former case, it should be published in the 'Philosophical Transactions' or 'Proceedings' 4. Whether it should be published in full or only in part or whether any material modifications are necessary 5. Which illustrations, if any, accompanying the paper should be reproduced General remarks |